专栏名称: 生信塔
新鲜出炉的生信热点方向,一茬接一茬的生信热点思路。生信塔提供思路设计、生信分析、文献复现登服务,想要创新思路的就来找小塔!
今天看啥  ›  专栏  ›  生信塔

纯生信修回,审稿人要求补充验证实验,我该怎么办?

生信塔  · 公众号  ·  · 2024-11-02 18:00
    

文章预览

投稿过纯生信的小伙伴肯定遇到过审稿人 要求补充验证实验 的问题,甚至一次修回3个审稿人每个人都要求补充实验。 Comment 1: It would be important to validate the results either using larger sample size or using bootstrapping or resampling to estimate the stability and reliability of the results. Comment 2: The results described were obtained by the second-use of the data published by another group. The second use itself is OK, but analyses are quite superficial, and no experimental validation (gene expression as well as potential usabilities of identified differentially expressed genes for vaccine development) was done. Comment 3: This is a study based purely on bioinformatics analysis. There are no convincing validation studies from clinical patients samples or experimental studies. The authors need to add more validation studies to support their conclusions. Comment 4: The biggest limitation of this study is that no laborator ………………………………

原文地址:访问原文地址
快照地址: 访问文章快照
总结与预览地址:访问总结与预览